MathisLine
2026 · Week 5

Weekly Streaming Tiers

Generated Sun Oct 11, 7:18 AM EDT · first kickoff Sun Oct 11, 9:30 AM EDT

Tier first, then order. The gap between tiers is real. Whether the order inside a tier is worth anything depends on the position — each section says which.

Defense / Special Teams

7 tiers · 28 teams · 2 played · 9 sportsbooksTier 1: HOU, JAX, CIN, NYJ, DEN, MIN, WAS
How to read this

pts is the points we expect the opponent to score. market and experts are where each source ranked this week's field. The order is 75% market and 25% expert consensus, the split that beat either source on its own over 90 past weeks — so the points column is deliberately not in order. A team sits higher than a better projection when the experts see something the line does not, and lower when they doubt it.

Inside a tier, the order still counts. Over six seasons the top third of a tier outscored the bottom third by 1.25 points — as much as dropping a whole tier costs (1.13). Narrower tiers do not remove this, so the ranking here is a real preference and not a tiebreaker.

Tier 17 close
1HOUvs TEN15.5 pts·market #1·experts #1
2JAXvs PHI16.8 pts·market #2·experts #5
3CINvs MIA18.5 pts·market #4·experts #3
4NYJvs CLE18.5 pts·market #4·experts #9
5DENvs LAC19.2 pts·market #6·experts #4
6MINvs NO19.8 pts·market #7·experts #2
7WASvs NYG19.0 pts·market #5·experts #8
Tier 26 close · 1 played
8PITvs IND20.5 pts·market #9·experts #6
9CLEvs NYJ21.0 pts·market #11·experts #7
10NEvs LV20.8 pts·market #10·experts #10
11ATLvs BAL20.0 pts·market #8·experts #16
12SEAvs SF21.8 pts·market #12·experts #12
13NOvs MIN21.8 pts·market #12·experts #15
5DALvs TBFinalL 16–24·allowed 24 (exp. 19.8)·2.0 fantasy
Tier 39 close
14CHIvs GB22.8 pts·market #16·experts #11
15NYGvs WAS22.5 pts·market #14·experts #17
16TENvs HOU22.5 pts·market #14·experts #25
17BALvs ATL23.5 pts·market #19·experts #14
18LACvs DEN22.8 pts·market #16·experts #22
19INDvs PIT23.0 pts·market #18·experts #18
20LVvs NE24.2 pts·market #20·experts #13
21GBvs CHI24.2 pts·market #20·experts #21
22DETvs ARI24.5 pts·market #22·experts #19
Tier 46 close
23PHIvs JAX24.8 pts·market #24·experts #20
24SFvs SEA24.8 pts·market #24·experts #24
25LAvs BUF25.5 pts·market #26·experts #23
26MIAvs CIN25.5 pts·market #26·experts #27
27BUFvs LA29.0 pts·market #27·experts #26
28ARIvs DET30.0 pts·market #28·experts #28
Tier 71 played
28TBvs DALFinalW 24–16·allowed 16 (exp. 27.8)·11.0 fantasy
T1T2T3T417131925HOUJAXCINNYJDENMINWASPITCLENEATLSEANOCHINYGTENBALLACINDLVGBDETPHISFLAMIABUFARI

Dot is the rank the board is sorted by. The bar is one standard deviation of expert disagreement — the same spread the tiers are cut from. Where neighbouring bars overlap the tier line between them is a close call; where a gap opens, it is not. Axis is consensus rank, best on the left.

Kickers

3 tiers · 28 players · 2 played · 9 sportsbooksTier 1: Evan McPherson, Jake Bates, Cam Little, Harrison Mevis, Jason Myers, Tyler Bass, Will Reichard, Ka'imi Fairbairn, Cairo Santos, Chris Boswell
How to read this

pts is the points we expect this offense to score. market and experts are where each source ranked this week's field. The order is 40% market and 60% expert consensus, the split that beat either source on its own over 90 past weeks — so the points column is deliberately not in order. A team sits higher than a better projection when the experts see something the line does not, and lower when they doubt it.

Inside a tier, the order is noise. Over six seasons the top third of a tier beat the bottom third by 0.18 points, indistinguishable from zero. Start whoever you like from the highest tier you can reach and decide it on matchup or roster.

Tier 110 close · 1 played
1Evan McPhersonCIN vs MIA25.5 pts·market #4·experts #1
2Jake BatesDET vs ARI30.0 pts·market #1·experts #3
3Cam LittleJAX vs PHI24.8 pts·market #6·experts #5
4Harrison MevisLA vs BUF29.0 pts·market #2·experts #8
5Jason MyersSEA vs SF24.8 pts·market #6·experts #6
6Tyler BassBUF vs LA25.5 pts·market #4·experts #9
7Will ReichardMIN vs NO21.8 pts·market #16·experts #2
8Ka'imi FairbairnHOU vs TEN22.5 pts·market #14·experts #4
9Cairo SantosCHI vs GB24.2 pts·market #8·experts #11
10Chris BoswellPIT vs IND23.0 pts·market #11·experts #10
1Brandon AubreyDAL vs TBFinalL 16–24·offense 16 (exp. 27.8)·5.0 fantasy
Tier 211 close · 1 played
11Chad RylandARI vs DET24.5 pts·market #7·experts #14
12Spencer ShraderIND vs PIT20.5 pts·market #20·experts #7
13Andy BorregalesNE vs LV24.2 pts·market #8·experts #16
14Eddy PineiroSF vs SEA21.8 pts·market #16·experts #12
15Nick FolkATL vs BAL23.5 pts·market #10·experts #17
16Wil LutzDEN vs LAC22.8 pts·market #12·experts #18
17Tyler LoopBAL vs ATL20.0 pts·market #21·experts #13
18Trey SmackGB vs CHI22.8 pts·market #12·experts #19
19Matt GayLV vs NE20.8 pts·market #19·experts #15
20Drew StevensWAS vs NYG22.5 pts·market #14·experts #21
21Blake GrupeNYJ vs CLE21.0 pts·market #18·experts #22
23Chase McLaughlinTB vs DALFinalW 24–16·offense 24 (exp. 19.8)·7.0 fantasy
Tier 37 close
22Daniel CarlsonNO vs MIN19.8 pts·market #22·experts #20
23Dominic ZvadaNYG vs WAS19.0 pts·market #24·experts #23
24Cameron DickerLAC vs DEN19.2 pts·market #23·experts #24
25Andre SzmytCLE vs NYJ18.5 pts·market #26·experts #25
26Jake ElliottPHI vs JAX16.8 pts·market #27·experts #26
27Riley PattersonMIA vs CIN18.5 pts·market #26·experts #27
28Joey SlyeTEN vs HOU15.5 pts·market #28·experts #28
T1T2T3191725Evan McPhersonJake BatesCam LittleHarrison MevisJason MyersTyler BassWill ReichardKa'imi FairbairnCairo SantosChris BoswellChad RylandSpencer ShraderAndy BorregalesEddy PineiroNick FolkWil LutzTyler LoopTrey SmackMatt GayDrew StevensBlake GrupeDaniel CarlsonDominic ZvadaCameron DickerAndre SzmytJake ElliottRiley PattersonJoey Slye

Dot is the rank the board is sorted by. The bar is one standard deviation of expert disagreement — the same spread the tiers are cut from. Where neighbouring bars overlap the tier line between them is a close call; where a gap opens, it is not. Axis is consensus rank, best on the left.

Tight Ends

5 tiers · 40 players · 2 played · 4 sportsbooksTier 1: Trey McBride, Brock Bowers, Dalton Kincaid, George Kittle, Sam LaPorta, Tyler Warren, Isaiah Likely, Tucker Kraft, Dallas Goedert
How to read this

pts is the fantasy points your league's scoring gives these lines, built from three betting markets on the player himself — his receptions line, his receiving-yards line, and his anytime-touchdown price, all shown beside it. Here the order is the points, because unlike the boards above there is no measured blend weight to apply: historical player props are not public, so this method has never been scored against a season. experts is where consensus ranked him, shown so you can see the disagreement rather than have it averaged away.

Inside a tier, the order is untested. The same check needs historical player props, which are not published, so there is no record to quote here. Read the ranking as the projection and nothing more.

Tier 19 close
1Trey McBrideARI vs DET19.1 pts·8.0 rec·82 yds·49% TD·experts #1
2Brock BowersLV vs NE16.4 pts·6.5 rec·74 yds·43% TD·experts #2
3Dalton KincaidBUF vs LA12.3 pts·4.5 rec·57 yds·36% TD·experts #7
4George KittleSF vs SEA12.1 pts·4.5 rec·54 yds·35% TD·experts #4
5Sam LaPortaDET vs ARI11.9 pts·4.5 rec·52 yds·38% TD·experts #4
6Tyler WarrenIND vs PIT11.3 pts·5.0 rec·44 yds·32% TD·experts #5
7Isaiah LikelyNYG vs WAS10.5 pts·4.5 rec·42 yds·30% TD·experts #6
8Tucker KraftGB vs CHI10.3 pts·4.5 rec·40 yds·31% TD·experts #10
9Dallas GoedertPHI vs JAX9.9 pts·4.5 rec·40 yds·23% TD·experts #16
Tier 28 close
10TJ HockensonMIN vs NO9.7 pts·4.5 rec·36 yds·25% TD·experts #12
11Colston LovelandCHI vs GB9.6 pts·4.0 rec·38 yds·31% TD·experts #11
12Dalton SchultzHOU vs TEN9.3 pts·4.5 rec·32 yds·25% TD·experts #18
13Juwan JohnsonNO vs MIN9.1 pts·4.5 rec·31 yds·25% TD·experts #10
14Harold FanninCLE vs NYJ9.0 pts·4.5 rec·28 yds·30% TD·experts #8
15Hunter HenryNE vs LV8.5 pts·3.5 rec·28 yds·36% TD·experts #17
16Mark AndrewsBAL vs ATL8.3 pts·3.5 rec·31 yds·29% TD·experts #15
17Brenton StrangeJAX vs PHI8.3 pts·3.5 rec·32 yds·25% TD·experts #19
Tier 37 close · 2 played
18Oronde GadsdenLAC vs DEN8.2 pts·3.5 rec·32 yds·24% TD·experts #21
19Kenyon SadiqNYJ vs CLE8.0 pts·3.5 rec·30 yds·27% TD·experts #14
20Pat FreiermuthPIT vs IND7.8 pts·3.5 rec·28 yds·25% TD·experts #20
21Michael MayerLV vs NE7.6 pts·3.5 rec·28 yds·22% TD·experts #23
22Chigoziem OkonkwoWAS vs NYG7.4 pts·3.5 rec·24 yds·24% TD·experts #26
23Mike GesickiCIN vs MIA7.2 pts·2.5 rec·30 yds·27% TD·experts #13
24Tyler HigbeeLA vs BUF6.6 pts·2.5 rec·24 yds·29% TD·experts #22
6Jake FergusonDAL vs TBFinalL 16–24·4.9 fantasy·proj 7.9
7Cade OttonTB vs DALFinalW 24–16·5.5 fantasy·proj 7.3
Tier 47 close
25Kyle PittsATL vs BAL6.4 pts·2.5 rec·24 yds·24% TD·experts #24
26AJ BarnerSEA vs SF6.2 pts·2.5 rec·22 yds·25% TD·experts #25
27Greg DulcichMIA vs CIN6.2 pts·2.5 rec·26 yds·19% TD·experts #27
28Darnell WashingtonPIT vs IND6.1 pts·2.5 rec·22 yds·22% TD·experts #29
29Evan EngramDEN vs LAC5.3 pts·2.5 rec·18 yds·18% TD·experts #28
30Gunnar HelmTEN vs HOU5.0 pts·2.5 rec·16 yds·15% TD·experts #31
31Colby ParkinsonLA vs BUF5.0 pts·1.5 rec·16 yds·30% TD·experts #32
Tier 59 close
32Mason TaylorNYJ vs CLE4.0 pts·1.5 rec·14 yds·19% TD·experts #33
33Dawson KnoxBUF vs LA3.7 pts·1.5 rec·11 yds·18% TD·experts #35
34Noah FantNO vs MIN3.6 pts·1.5 rec·14 yds·12% TD·experts #30
35Eli RaridonNE vs LV3.5 pts·1.5 rec·10 yds·17% TD·experts #34
36Cole KmetCHI vs GB3.3 pts·1.5 rec·10 yds·14% TD·experts #36
37Elijah HigginsARI vs DET3.2 pts·1.5 rec·10 yds·12% TD·experts #37
38Jonnu SmithGB vs CHI2.9 pts·1.5 rec·8 yds·11% TD·experts #38
39Will KacmarekMIA vs CIN2.6 pts·1.5 rec·6 yds·8% TD·experts #40
40Austin HooperATL vs BAL2.5 pts·1.0 rec·7 yds·13% TD·experts #39
T1T2T3T4T51122334Trey McBrideBrock BowersDalton KincaidGeorge KittleSam LaPortaTyler WarrenIsaiah LikelyTucker KraftDallas GoedertTJ HockensonColston LovelandDalton SchultzJuwan JohnsonHarold FanninHunter HenryMark AndrewsBrenton StrangeOronde GadsdenKenyon SadiqPat FreiermuthMichael MayerChigoziem OkonkwoMike GesickiTyler HigbeeKyle PittsAJ BarnerGreg DulcichDarnell WashingtonEvan EngramGunnar HelmColby ParkinsonMason TaylorDawson KnoxNoah FantEli RaridonCole KmetElijah HigginsJonnu SmithWill KacmarekAustin Hooper

Dot is the rank the board is sorted by. The bar is one standard deviation of expert disagreement — the same spread the tiers are cut from. Where neighbouring bars overlap the tier line between them is a close call; where a gap opens, it is not. Axis is consensus rank, best on the left.

Tier 19 close
1Trey McBrideARI vs DET15.1 pts·8.0 rec·82 yds·49% TD·experts #1
2Brock BowersLV vs NE13.2 pts·6.5 rec·74 yds·43% TD·experts #2
3Dalton KincaidBUF vs LA10.1 pts·4.5 rec·57 yds·36% TD·experts #7
4George KittleSF vs SEA9.8 pts·4.5 rec·54 yds·35% TD·experts #4
5Sam LaPortaDET vs ARI9.7 pts·4.5 rec·52 yds·38% TD·experts #4
6Tyler WarrenIND vs PIT8.8 pts·5.0 rec·44 yds·32% TD·experts #5
7Isaiah LikelyNYG vs WAS8.3 pts·4.5 rec·42 yds·30% TD·experts #6
8Tucker KraftGB vs CHI8.0 pts·4.5 rec·40 yds·31% TD·experts #10
9Dallas GoedertPHI vs JAX7.7 pts·4.5 rec·40 yds·23% TD·experts #16
Tier 211 close
10Colston LovelandCHI vs GB7.6 pts·4.0 rec·38 yds·31% TD·experts #11
11TJ HockensonMIN vs NO7.4 pts·4.5 rec·36 yds·25% TD·experts #12
12Dalton SchultzHOU vs TEN7.0 pts·4.5 rec·32 yds·25% TD·experts #18
13Juwan JohnsonNO vs MIN6.8 pts·4.5 rec·31 yds·25% TD·experts #10
14Harold FanninCLE vs NYJ6.8 pts·4.5 rec·28 yds·30% TD·experts #8
15Hunter HenryNE vs LV6.7 pts·3.5 rec·28 yds·36% TD·experts #17
16Mark AndrewsBAL vs ATL6.6 pts·3.5 rec·31 yds·29% TD·experts #15
17Brenton StrangeJAX vs PHI6.5 pts·3.5 rec·32 yds·25% TD·experts #19
18Oronde GadsdenLAC vs DEN6.4 pts·3.5 rec·32 yds·24% TD·experts #21
19Kenyon SadiqNYJ vs CLE6.3 pts·3.5 rec·30 yds·27% TD·experts #14
20Pat FreiermuthPIT vs IND6.0 pts·3.5 rec·28 yds·25% TD·experts #20
Tier 310 close · 2 played
21Mike GesickiCIN vs MIA5.9 pts·2.5 rec·30 yds·27% TD·experts #13
22Michael MayerLV vs NE5.9 pts·3.5 rec·28 yds·22% TD·experts #23
23Chigoziem OkonkwoWAS vs NYG5.6 pts·3.5 rec·24 yds·24% TD·experts #26
24Tyler HigbeeLA vs BUF5.3 pts·2.5 rec·24 yds·29% TD·experts #22
25Kyle PittsATL vs BAL5.1 pts·2.5 rec·24 yds·24% TD·experts #24
26AJ BarnerSEA vs SF5.0 pts·2.5 rec·22 yds·25% TD·experts #25
27Greg DulcichMIA vs CIN4.9 pts·2.5 rec·26 yds·19% TD·experts #27
28Darnell WashingtonPIT vs IND4.8 pts·2.5 rec·22 yds·22% TD·experts #29
29Colby ParkinsonLA vs BUF4.2 pts·1.5 rec·16 yds·30% TD·experts #32
30Evan EngramDEN vs LAC4.1 pts·2.5 rec·18 yds·18% TD·experts #28
6Jake FergusonDAL vs TBFinalL 16–24·3.4 fantasy·proj 6.2
7Cade OttonTB vs DALFinalW 24–16·4.0 fantasy·proj 5.6
Tier 410 close
31Gunnar HelmTEN vs HOU3.8 pts·2.5 rec·16 yds·15% TD·experts #31
32Mason TaylorNYJ vs CLE3.2 pts·1.5 rec·14 yds·19% TD·experts #33
33Dawson KnoxBUF vs LA2.9 pts·1.5 rec·11 yds·18% TD·experts #35
34Noah FantNO vs MIN2.8 pts·1.5 rec·14 yds·12% TD·experts #30
35Eli RaridonNE vs LV2.8 pts·1.5 rec·10 yds·17% TD·experts #34
36Cole KmetCHI vs GB2.6 pts·1.5 rec·10 yds·14% TD·experts #36
37Elijah HigginsARI vs DET2.4 pts·1.5 rec·10 yds·12% TD·experts #37
38Jonnu SmithGB vs CHI2.1 pts·1.5 rec·8 yds·11% TD·experts #38
39Austin HooperATL vs BAL2.0 pts·1.0 rec·7 yds·13% TD·experts #39
40Will KacmarekMIA vs CIN1.9 pts·1.5 rec·6 yds·8% TD·experts #40
T1T2T3T41122334Trey McBrideBrock BowersDalton KincaidGeorge KittleSam LaPortaTyler WarrenIsaiah LikelyTucker KraftDallas GoedertColston LovelandTJ HockensonDalton SchultzJuwan JohnsonHarold FanninHunter HenryMark AndrewsBrenton StrangeOronde GadsdenKenyon SadiqPat FreiermuthMike GesickiMichael MayerChigoziem OkonkwoTyler HigbeeKyle PittsAJ BarnerGreg DulcichDarnell WashingtonColby ParkinsonEvan EngramGunnar HelmMason TaylorDawson KnoxNoah FantEli RaridonCole KmetElijah HigginsJonnu SmithAustin HooperWill Kacmarek

Dot is the rank the board is sorted by. The bar is one standard deviation of expert disagreement — the same spread the tiers are cut from. Where neighbouring bars overlap the tier line between them is a close call; where a gap opens, it is not. Axis is consensus rank, best on the left.

Quarterbacks

6 tiers · 28 players · 2 played · 10 sportsbooksTier 1: Josh Allen, Matthew Stafford, Jared Goff, Jacoby Brissett
How to read this

pts is the fantasy points your league's scoring gives these lines, built from four betting markets on the player himself — his passing-yards and rushing-yards lines, and the prices on his passing touchdowns and interceptions, all shown beside it. The last two come from the odds rather than the posted number on purpose: every quarterback on the slate is listed at the same half-interception and nearly all at the same one-and-a-half touchdowns, so those lines separate nobody while the prices behind them separate everybody. Opp D is where the defence he faces sits on the D/ST board above, so Opp D #1 is the toughest draw of the week; it does not move the order, since the matchup is already inside every line. Here the order is the points, because unlike the boards above there is no measured blend weight to apply: historical player props are not public, so this method has never been scored against a season. experts is where consensus ranked him, shown so you can see the disagreement rather than have it averaged away.

Inside a tier, the order is untested, for the same reason as tight ends: the check needs historical player props and those are not published. One caveat this board has and the others do not — passing yards and touchdowns are priced by nine or ten sportsbooks, but interceptions by exactly one. That term is a real matchup read and is kept, but a single book cannot be checked against anyone.

Tier 14 close
1Josh AllenBUF vs LA25.1 pts·244 yds·1.7 TD·0.8 INT·36 rush·Opp D #25·experts #1
2Matthew StaffordLA vs BUF24.1 pts·280 yds·2.3 TD·0.7 INT·Opp D #27·experts #3
3Jared GoffDET vs ARI23.9 pts·280 yds·2.2 TD·0.5 INT·Opp D #28·experts #2
4Jacoby BrissettARI vs DET23.8 pts·268 yds·1.9 TD·0.0 INT·Opp D #22·experts #5
Tier 24 close · 1 played
5Joe BurrowCIN vs MIA22.9 pts·252 yds·2.0 TD·0.5 INT·Opp D #26·experts #4
6Drake MayeNE vs LV22.2 pts·224 yds·1.7 TD·0.7 INT·32 rush·Opp D #20·experts #6
7Brock PurdySF vs SEA21.9 pts·228 yds·1.6 TD·0.0 INT·24 rush·Opp D #12·experts #8
8Trevor LawrenceJAX vs PHI20.7 pts·226 yds·1.7 TD·0.7 INT·14 rush·Opp D #23·experts #7
3Dak PrescottDAL vs TBFinalL 16–24·14.6 fantasy·proj 24.3
Tier 36 close
9Jayden DanielsWAS vs NYG20.3 pts·194 yds·1.5 TD·0.6 INT·30 rush·Opp D #15·experts #9
10CJ StroudHOU vs TEN19.3 pts·238 yds·1.5 TD·0.5 INT·Opp D #16·experts #13
11Sam DarnoldSEA vs SF19.2 pts·232 yds·1.7 TD·0.6 INT·Opp D #24·experts #15
12Bo NixDEN vs LAC19.0 pts·220 yds·1.5 TD·0.8 INT·14 rush·Opp D #18·experts #10
13Jordan LoveGB vs CHI18.9 pts·238 yds·1.6 TD·0.8 INT·Opp D #14·experts #11
14Tyson BagentCHI vs GB18.8 pts·216 yds·1.6 TD·0.7 INT·12 rush·Opp D #21·experts #19
Tier 44 close
15Michael PenixATL vs BAL18.4 pts·218 yds·1.5 TD·0.0 INT·Opp D #17·experts #23
16Kyler MurrayMIN vs NO18.1 pts·212 yds·1.4 TD·0.6 INT·18 rush·Opp D #13·experts #14
17Jalen HurtsPHI vs JAX18.1 pts·186 yds·1.0 TD·0.0 INT·26 rush·Opp D #2·experts #16
18Deshaun WatsonCLE vs NYJ18.1 pts·198 yds·1.3 TD·0.6 INT·26 rush·Opp D #4·experts #18
Tier 55 close
19Aaron RodgersPIT vs IND17.9 pts·224 yds·1.6 TD·0.6 INT·Opp D #19·experts #17
20Tyler ShoughNO vs MIN17.9 pts·236 yds·1.3 TD·0.8 INT·Opp D #6·experts #12
21Geno SmithNYJ vs CLE17.8 pts·204 yds·1.3 TD·0.0 INT·10 rush·Opp D #9·experts #24
22Justin HerbertLAC vs DEN17.3 pts·200 yds·1.2 TD·0.8 INT·24 rush·Opp D #5·experts #22
23Kirk CousinsLV vs NE17.0 pts·232 yds·1.5 TD·0.8 INT·Opp D #10·experts #20
Tier 65 close · 1 played
24Tyler HuntleyBAL vs ATL16.8 pts·174 yds·1.2 TD·0.6 INT·28 rush·Opp D #11·experts #25
25Malik WillisMIA vs CIN16.8 pts·190 yds·1.0 TD·0.6 INT·32 rush·Opp D #3·experts #27
26Daniel JonesIND vs PIT15.6 pts·209 yds·1.2 TD·0.8 INT·Opp D #8·experts #26
27Jameis WinstonNYG vs WAS14.4 pts·200 yds·1.2 TD·0.9 INT·Opp D #7·experts #21
28Cam WardTEN vs HOU13.4 pts·190 yds·0.9 TD·0.7 INT·10 rush·Opp D #1·experts #28
14Jalon DanielsTB vs DALFinalW 24–16·15.9 fantasy·proj 17.8
T1T2T3T4T5T6191725Josh AllenMatthew StaffordJared GoffJacoby BrissettJoe BurrowDrake MayeBrock PurdyTrevor LawrenceJayden DanielsCJ StroudSam DarnoldBo NixJordan LoveTyson BagentMichael PenixKyler MurrayJalen HurtsDeshaun WatsonAaron RodgersTyler ShoughGeno SmithJustin HerbertKirk CousinsTyler HuntleyMalik WillisDaniel JonesJameis WinstonCam Ward

Dot is the rank the board is sorted by. The bar is one standard deviation of expert disagreement — the same spread the tiers are cut from. Where neighbouring bars overlap the tier line between them is a close call; where a gap opens, it is not. Axis is consensus rank, best on the left.